May 2015

Having trouble reading this email? View it in your browser.

  Issue: May 2015

  Feature | Public Consultations & Events | Publications | International | Training



In our feature article, we share our deep concerns as energy regulators about a key EU financial market regulation (MiFID II) which we believe will have serious negative impacts on European energy markets, making the “Energy Union” unachievable.

On a more positive note, CEER loves great videos. This is why we bring you a series of EU energy videos produced for the FSR-CEER training courses.

Director Borchardt, European Commission, talks about the Internal Energy Market.  Sue Harrison, DECC, explains about agreeing and implementing Network Codes. View these and more videos on issues such as electricity and the Gas Target Model.

Our Madrid Forum presentations (Energy Union, security of supply, LNG and storage) are now online.

Don’t miss out on CEER’s training courses for staff of regulatory authorities (see Training below).  Next courses are on Wholesale Market Monitoring  (20-21 May) and on Retail Markets (23-24 June).

Last chance to register for the World Forum on Energy Regulation, Istanbul (25-28 May) !

Financial Market Regulation (MiFID II) threatens the Energy Union objective

CEER has advised the European Commission of the risks to energy market liquidity and prices faced by energy consumers of the proposed changes to financial market regulations.

Links between Financial (MiFID II) and Wholesale Energy (REMIT) Regulation
In the wake of the financial crisis, the European Commission strengthened financial regulation to have a more resilient financial system. Energy trading is subject to stringent control under the Regulation of wholesale energy market integrity and transparency (REMIT) and the EU 3rd Energy Package laws. A review of the Market in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID II) introduces tighter rules not only for the financial services sector but also for energy companies. MiFID II includes a specific exemption, the so-called “REMIT carve out”, for certain wholesale energy products already covered under REMIT.

Energy regulators very much support the goals of financial regulation. However, we believe that the current proposals for MiFID II (level 2) legislation ("Delegated Acts") will narrow unduly the scope of the exemption agreed by the legislators in the primary MiFID II law.

The European Commission (DG FISMA) is currently preparing (for adoption in July 2015) the MiFID II (“level 2”) rules based on the advice of the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA). Energy regulators (CEER and ACER) have major concerns regarding Section C6 (the definition of “must be physically settled”) and Section C7 (contracts deemed to be “equivalent”) in ESMA’s advice.

The problem of the proposed (level 2) rules – reduced liquidity in energy markets

CEER believes that subjecting firms trading in energy to additional regulation intended for financial markets leads not only to an increased regulatory burden but also could have profound negative effects on the cost of trading in the energy market, potentially reducing liquidity and undermining efforts to create a competitive Internal Energy Market. This would have a negative impact on prices for energy consumers and on security of supply, and ultimately threatens the Energy Union objective.

Let's have "Better Regulation"
CEER urgently appeals to the European Commission, in its deliberations with the other EU Institutions on the proposed changes in EU financial regulation, to commit to its “better regulation” agenda and avoid placing additional obligations on firms trading energy who are already subject to effective supervision by energy regulators under REMIT.

Simply, CEER advocates that wholesale energy contracts which are "physically settled" should be subject to REMIT, and to protect the "REMIT carve-out" as it stands in the MiFID II primary legislation. See CEER advice to the European Commission, our advice to ESMA and our Press Release.

Public Consultations & Events

Visit our website to be updated on our future consultations and events.

Training for regulators

Register now for our next Training courses:
- Wholesale Market Monitoring course (20-21 May)
- Retail Market Monitoring course (23-24 June)


There's still time to register for the 6th World Forum on Energy Regulation in Istanbul on 25-28 May 2015. To register click here.


Tel: +322 788 7330 or
+ 32 484 668 599